Dental Nachos Presents: Practice Partnerships, Valuations & the Current Dental Deal Landscape

This week, the Dental Amigos welcome Matthew Howard, Director and leader of the Dental Transaction Advisory Group at Blue & Co., LLC, alongside Paul Goodman, founder of Dental Nachos, and Rob Montgomery, dental attorney and founder of Your Dental Lawyer. Matthew is part of a Top 55 CPA firm with a dedicated team of 20 dental professionals, supporting approximately 400 dentists annually.
In this episode, Matthew shares his experience advising dental professionals on practice transactions and explores the current dental deal landscape with Paul and Rob. They discuss practice partnerships, valuations, EBITDA, DSO and DPO transactions, and the considerations involved in selling or transitioning a dental practice. Rob also shares his legal perspective on deal structures, negotiations, and the importance of having trusted legal and accounting advisors working together to help dentists make informed decisions.
To learn more about Matthew and the companies represented in this episode, visit:
• Blue & Co., LLC: www.blueandco.com
• Dental Nachos: www.dentalnachos.com
• Your Dental Lawyer: www.yourdentallawyer.com
For more information about the webinar recording, visit Dental Nachos or text BLUE to 215-543-6454.
Listeners who want to reach Paul can do so at Paul@DentalNachos.com and those who want to reach Rob can do so at Rob@RMontgomery-law.com.
FULL EPISODE TRANSCRIPT
Paul Goodman
Welcome to Dental Nachos TV. I am Dr. Nacho. I'm thrilled to be joined by two of my friends, Nacho sponsors, who are going to help us understand practice partnerships, valuations, and the current dental landscape for deals, DSOs, DPOs, and private practice transitions. Rob and Matt are fantastic resources for you at all ages and stages of your dental journey. To connect with them, you can do so by texting BLUE to 215-543-6454. I want Matt to just jump in here for a minute before we start. Matt, in your daily life, helping dentists cry less inside, because that's what we do here in Dental Nachos: smile more and cry less. If someone just heard of Blue & Co., what are you doing on a daily, day-to-day basis to increase smiling and reduce crying for your dental clients?
Matthew Howard
Yeah, that's a great question. I mean, ultimately, dentists want to thrive. They want to thrive, and they want to not fear what they don't know, and part of being a CPA partner is helping them understand what is going on in their financial world, and—and how does that intersect with business decisions? How does that intersect with should I bring an associate? Should I partner? And all the great things that we're going to talk today, but really just helping them have that, you know, that GPS in the background talking in their ear, saying, "Hey, this is what we need to be thinking about today. This is what we need to be thinking about as we plan for the three-letter word called tax, you know, coming up here at the end of the year." Those are the things that we try to solve every day.
Paul Goodman
I like that, and I know we talk about KPIs, and I had the pleasure of seeing you speak, and I know you have invented your own. But I don't know if you remember. EBITDA is important, but this is mine. Espida, in case anyone wants to know, this is the stress building inside towards dentist annoyance, tracked by the number of times you cry inside a day. So I think EBITDA and Espida are equally important in the life of a dentist, and we have my good friend Rob Montgomery. We've worked together for years. Rob's been on many times. He helps you avoid decisions that make you cry inside. But Rob, just before we get started with our Q&A and our talk, anything you'd like to share about your day-to-day basis helping dentists cry less inside?
Rob Montgomery
Yeah, I mean, I think a lot of people know about our practice here. Yourdentallawyer.com is our website, and, you know, we're helping dentists do the legal end of a lot of the transactions and the things that—that Matt helps with on the financial support. And, you know, for me, Matt and I have had this conversation over beers. We've had it, you know, in, like, breakout sessions. We've had it standing in the hallway of, you know, different conferences. So Matt and I do talk about this in—in—in a way that's—that's meaningful. So this is none of this is staged. You know, we have a great working relationship. I love working with Matt, and, you know, let me just say at the outset what a lot of my clients, if there's anybody here listening, have already heard from me. You know, we as lawyers, I'd like to tell you that we're the most important part of your team, and maybe we are in a way. But we as lawyers can do the best piece of legal work ever. We can't make a bad deal good, though, and when I say we can't make a bad deal good, it's because somebody has done something that is financially not in their best interest from a cash flow standpoint or a personal standpoint. But we can't change those numbers. We can't change the outcome, and—and that's why it's so important to work with somebody who is a good dental-focused CPA to guide you through this process. And Matt and I are going to talk about, I think, what some of the misconceptions are today about valuations and cash flow. It's especially important when you're looking at partnerships, whether it's a dentist-to-dentist partnership, or if you're looking to—to sell to a DSO, you know, so many times when I see people say, "Oh, I did this horrible deal. I can't believe this deal was turned out to be so bad." I look at that, and I know the reason why it's bad is because they didn't do the right planning, they didn't have the right expectations, they didn't do the right things to prepare themselves to understand what they were doing before, and so let me just say, conclude with my intro here. I'll wrap up my opening statement, Paul, by saying the—the great thing about this and everything that you're going to listen to here, and despite all the horror stories we see on Nachos and other places, all of these things are avoidable. All you have to do is do the right thing before, do the right steps, take the right steps with the right people at the right time, and you will ensure success.
Paul Goodman
I love that. Before I go to Matt, we have many people watching in here. I like to preserve Zoom HIPAA, but I see some of my friends here in the chat. If you have questions for these two experts, you ask them. And, you know, Rob, you were part of the transitions basketball team show back in the day. And, you know, who's LeBron? That's what I want to know. Who's LeBron on the team? Because it is embarrassment of sports riches here in Philadelphia from Saquon Barkley's, Jalen Hurts's, and LeBron James. So I will now go to you, Matt, and ask like this. I want to use this example. If I was speaking on behalf of all dentists and I wanted to give a public service announcement to potential patients that was mainly altruistic in helping them, of course they might go to their dentist more. I would say, if you are above the age of 40, you should be going to get your teeth cleaned more than two times a year. When you go to get your teeth cleaned more than two times a year, your dental hygienist can identify problems before they become too big. And even if you think you're the best brusher and flosser on earth, once you have had 40 years of life, it makes a lot of sense to go to your dental hygienist more than two times a year. That is my public service announcement for people out there. If you were speaking on behalf of all accountants, and you just wanted people listening in—I got people who've been dentist for 40 years here, people who've been dentist for four months here—if you just want to give them some public service announcement about working with a dental-focused accountant, what they should be paying attention to, what most of your clients wish they did sooner, what would that be?
Matthew Howard
Yeah, that's—that's a fantastic question. I—I love the idea of this, that, you know, there—whether you're on the onset of your career as a dentist and thinking about owning. And I'm a weird dental CPA, right? I'm not your all-day, every day in the tax code. I am working on about 400 dental deals, and a lot of those with Rob. You know, as we think about, you know, getting doctors out of practice that want to be out of ownership, and then getting buyers into practices as they try to think about what do I want my career to be like, right? And so, I guess if I had a public service announcement, that please don't get enamored with multiples, please don't get enamored by...
Paul Goodman
What does that mean? Because you're doing a little mesial and distal, so I'm like, "Hey, Rob, this mesial part of your tooth is breaking down." You don't really know. So I understand multiples, but now just six-year-oldify that for the people just watching. And what does multiples mean?
Matthew Howard
Well, everybody's talking about EBITDA. You talked about, and again, I have my flare of EBITDA and thinking about it. And all I'm saying is, you know, people think and hear their buddies or their girlfriends down the road that say, "Hey, I got 8x EBITDA," and they get enamored by that. That sounds really good, and that sounds really interesting. But as Rob and I think we'll unpack a little bit later today, is, like, thinking about, guys, I'll pay you 20x multiple for your practice today, but for the next 10 years, you have to grow by 10% every year, right? Like, so structure and multiple are meaningless without each other. And I think...
Paul Goodman
You're basically—for me to interject. I don't interrupt. I just interject with brilliant ideas. Rob does my wife. That's what she says all the time. Don't ask her. Just take my word for it. I want to interject because I can think like a dentist as you're sharing this wisdom, like Rob did. If you would just take a moment to help our audience understand what EBITDA is like inside of a practice. So I, if—if someone's watching in who has a $3 million, $2 million dental practice, and they say, "Hey, Matt, at the end of the year, my accountant says I make $800,000 a year. That's my EBITDA." You would say that's not your EBITDA. So if you could just frame it for them, so they can stick with this conversation, because it's going to be a big part of it. How would you define it in an easy-to-understand way using that $2 million practice? Dennis thinks they make 800 grand. Oh, I can get 7x of 800 grand. That's 5.6 million. And you might say, "Oh, I time out a second." Your EBITDA is not 800. Now you tell us.
Matthew Howard
Yeah, and you've heard my spiel. And disclaimer: if you say this to a friend, they will make fun of you because I've completely and utterly made it up. But thinking about EBITDA not as EBITDA, but as EBITDA, okay, and thinking about it's basically trying to summarize it in the most, you know, elementary style as possible, it's your earnings. Okay, after debt service, that's the interest, the I. After taxes, federal taxes. It does include payroll taxes and all that fun stuff. So before, you know, federal taxes, before debt service, okay, and before replacing equipment, which shows up through depreciation and amortization conceptually. Okay, so it's your earnings, and then what is the DANC or the NC that I add to the end of it? It's after normalizing compensation, and if you're a, you know, sole proprietor, guess what? You don't pay yourself any, you know, W-2, and it's all falling to the bottom line. If you're an S corp, you're paying yourself reasonable compensation, right? And so, all I'm saying is this: you got to normalize yourself, owner. If you're paying yourself way below or way high, normalizing that first is really how we get to EBITDA, which is consistent. Conceptually, what is left over after the clinical job is done, which is easy...
Paul Goodman
Yeah. So, what someone would make if they ran their business with an associate in your spot, and you could potentially be the associate. Is that a reasonable way to start to think about this process?
Matthew Howard
Yeah. It's—it's—it's thinking about your clinical efforts. What would it take to replace those clinical efforts? Do that math. What falls out at the bottom then is conceptually your EBITDA or EBITDA.
Paul Goodman
And, you know, I don't want—I don't let Rob jump in, man, but I know we're talking numbers. We're going to get to deal sections in a second. But if in that $2 million practice, the owner is making $800,000, but they are producing 1.2 million of that themselves, their associate compensation could be something like $400,000, leaving 400, which I just want to show off, Rob, my fractions. That's 20% of 2 million. So that 400,000 is 20% of 2 million. You're making 400 as an associate, and there's $400,000 additional money, which could be rebooted. I know that probably to accountants makes you cringe, but to a dentist, that's a, you know, apparently at one time people were only doing math on the back of napkins. That was the only time back-of-the-napkins math, no calculators. You just got a napkin. Who has a napkin? I need to do fractions. So that is the back-of-the-napkin math here. So just to set us up for this conversation, whether it's the Nacho team, the Job Connect team here watching in, or dentist that, like, you're looking at practices and you're helping them make next best decision as they want to transition. And transitioning could be selling to a private practice dentist, could be selling to a DSO, could be selling to a DPO, could be a partnership buyout. Right? Could be selling a portion to their associates. Are those things you see, Rob? Did I miss anything in the person who owns the $2 million practice? I think you covered.
Rob Montgomery
I think you covered most of, you know, the—the plausible options. Yeah, and I think probably realistically, there's really, you know, the three of them. You're going to sell to a DSO. You're going to sell either in whole or part to your associate, so it's really two subparts, you know, subparts of the second one...
Paul Goodman
Or sell to another buyer and be done with your practice and move somewhere to be a sommelier in Napa Valley because that's my goal. But...
Rob Montgomery
Sounds good.
Paul Goodman
So in this scenario, Rob and Matt, we're talking about deal structures, deals, private practice deals, and I'll ask you some questions to talk about. So we could have somebody watching in saying, "I have a $2 million practice, and I find this to be one of the most positive things about dentistry because there's some fairly negative things. People tell us they hate us, telling insurance, and they say there's no way I can sell this to a younger dentist because they could never get a loan this size because they have too much dental school debt." What would you say to that dentist, Matt, to help them understand the current climate of dental-focused banks and their desire to lend to dentists?
Matthew Howard
Yeah, that's—that's one of the best parts working in this industry is that, you know, capital is available. It's not without restrictions. It's not without guidance. You know, thinking about you do need to have no bank wants to lend money to somebody that doesn't have any liquid cash in their personal, you know, no margin for error in their personal life. So typically, seven to 10% is the guidance that I've kind of learned over time of the—the purchase price that you're going after would conceptually be nice to have in the bank account to be blessed by the bank and the partner, you know, the banking partner. You know, other things like, you know, you need to have a connection point, and this comes into play with partnerships too. Is, you know, an associate buying into a partner is there needs to be a connection point on the production that you're buying into, and what you've been able to do in the past. We don't want an associate that's been doing a half million dollars in collections to be buying a million dollars of dentist collections, you know, and not have a resource to deliver that amount of work.
Rob Montgomery
I just stop you there. This is really important, you know, and I think this is where people kind of trip up a lot of times. And—and—and let me just kind of let's go back on that, Matt, because you and I have talked about this in the partnership buy-in context a lot, so if this is what Matt is saying is, you know, and—and—and take just take another step back, in a dental practice partnership, the lion's share of the income that you're going to make is producing dentistry, and so what you split as a partner is—is really just sort of the gravy with that. So you don't necessarily want to buy a percentage of the practice that you're not producing because now you've paid for maybe half, but you're only getting 25% of the production. Now, whether or not that works out from a cash flow standpoint, that particular scenario, that's why—that's why you got to work with Matt, but oftentimes that's a red flag for me. Where I say, "Hey, you know, let's—what's the CPA say?" Because you're now paying for half of this thing, but you're realistically only getting a quarter, and that's where a lot of times the cash flow doesn't work because you're borrowing a giant number that you may not be able to make enough to justify, and that's—that's a really key scenario that you need to put before your account to help you crunch those numbers and understand what what they are, so you can make an informed decision.
Matthew Howard
Right, and—and another cool thing about dental is that as an associate, if the deal is done correctly and you're buying in, and there is a connection point between how much you produce and your future partner, AKA there's some alignment in your percentage owned and the amount of production that you produce in the global ownership dental-specific production. If there's a connection point there, typically, I would say I'm making up my own statistics, which is always dangerous. But I'm a CPA, so I can do it. 90% of the time, you get—you're buying in, you're financing it all, your cash flow is getting incrementally better, and oh, by the way, you're paying off big chunks of equity because typically it's like a 10-year note, right? So you are literally getting a 15-ish, 20-ish percent rate of return on your investment if a deal is done right with the right structure, right? It can be an amazing opportunity, but there's also things that go wrong.
Rob Montgomery
And let me jump in on that, Paul, before you come, because, you know, I'm the lawyer. My job here is just to—to throw a wet blanket on all—all the fun. But where one of the places where I do see people go wrong, kind of back on the theme we're talking about here, is where you look at the valuation of the practice. Everybody's, "What's the valuation? What's the valuation?" And whether we're talking about in the DSO transaction or we're talking about in a—in a partnership, you know, in a buy-in with an associate, and people think, like, especially in the associate buy-in world, well, if the practice is valued at 3 million and somebody's buying 40%, then 1.2 million should be the number, and, you know, maybe—maybe not. You know, and you can't just assume that that's a good deal because you need to know all these other things. You know, how is the deal being structured? How much are you going to be producing? And what I will say is where we—where we see a lot of people kind of get mixed up, and they find out after the fact that they did a bad deal because they skip this step. They just assume that, yeah, you know, if it's 40% of the valuation, then therefore that's a good deal for me, the seller, and a good deal for the buyer. Again, but not necessarily because sometimes that number can be too good for the associate or too good for the seller, and so, you know, you unlike other deals and business deals where you just want to sell something and maximize your sale price. When you're looking at these partnerships, you really, you have to think about this as a seesaw. You know, you want this to be, you know, and it's so trite to say, but a win-win for both parties. You want it to be that the seesaw is just kind of—kind of balanced for both. You know?
Paul Goodman
I would say, Robin, we've spent so much time talking. You want both parties to be glad they did it, right? Wins, wins. I think to me, as a dentist, right, and I'm not disagreeing. I'm just sort of adding context. At the end of you, I say, "I'm glad I did this thing. I'm glad I sold to this person. I'm glad they bought the practice." Right?
Rob Montgomery
Right. Well, but especially in partnerships, even in practice sales, that's one thing. You've sold. You've gone off. You know. And if the person does thinks that they paid too much, whatever. But if—if you're a 50% partner who you're working next to every day and having lunch with, and—and—and you know this is your—your—your business partner in the most important professional aspect of your—of your life, like, you don't want to be in that relationship where somebody feels that they've been hoodwinked and it doesn't work for them because that is not a strategy for long-term partnership success. There can't be a winner and a loser in this deal. The stakes are too high, and when—and what we see sometimes is, "Hey, I'm—my practice is valued at at 3 million. I'm going to sell this for a million and a half," and it's like, well, the associate can—can service this debt. It could—could use that the profit that they're going to get off of this, and essentially pay that in two years. Like, if that's the case, that's too good of a deal for the associate, you know, and—and similarly, as Matt said...
Paul Goodman
This is why work as we always talk about working with advisors who do this every day is so key. And I wanted you guys to talk about this next. If you want to make a dentist cringe, walk up to another party. I'm not joking, both of you. Walk up to a dentist and say, "Hey," and smile. "Do I need a full mouth rehab?" And they're going to say, "I need to see you in my office. We need to take X-rays." And say, "No, no, no, no, no. I would like you to tell me right now because I went on ChatGPT and I look if I need a full math rehab. So right now, I would like to talk about this. You know, there could be a. I'm turning 49 in two weeks. There could be a 49-year-old dentist who has a $2 million practice." Who wants to make good decisions with their career? They don't know if they want to sell. They don't know what they're going to do next, and they can go to UMAT and do a practice valuation and appraisal. And maybe this cost is in the $5,000 range. Maybe it's more. Maybe it's less. And they say, "Well, I could just ask a broker to value it. Why do I need an accountant to do this? Could you just explain and educate this group of why it's a really good idea to invest that money into getting a true understanding of where your practice is at before you go to X Y Z D S O, before you have dinner with your associate dentist, and say, because you can never unsay things, right? You can never, you can't do it. So if you say to your associate, 'This practice worth 2 million, and you can buy 50% for 500 grand.' Never unhear that. So just talk, and Rob, you can add after Matt. I know it's a why is that a valuable thing for a 49-year-old dentist to do, not with an agenda of selling tomorrow, selling to a DSO, just as a standalone good practice.
Matthew Howard
Well, I mean, hate to be the web link. I know that's Rob's, you know, role here in this, but I'll purely...
Rob Montgomery
Mr. Sunshine, Rainbows and Unicorns, Matt.
Matthew Howard
Well, you know, unfortunately, the worst calls a year I get. It used to be office managers stealing from practice. Those are horrible. They still happen occasionally, but it's gotten a little bit better over time. The worst calls I get doing, you know, 400 deals a year. I would say a good subset of those, maybe 250 to 300 of those, are business valuations for buy-sell, litigious, all the fun things that happen in dental world. The worst ones we get, though, are the ones where something happened to Doc. And so to me, if you are looking to have something on file, that means that that basically is a gift to your loved one. That says, "I—if something happens to me, we already have a relationship with a good attorney. We already have a good valuation on file. We've—we know what's the good, the bad, and the ugly. Guess what? You can be on market in a week instead of a month and a half," and as you guys know, as all the horror stories that we've heard of great dentist that have had health issues and taken them out of the chair, to me that is—that's the plan and protect type thing. A, it is the best measure of how am I doing when it comes to if I'm creating value, I'm probably doing better, right? So it does solve that issue. But to me, if I could talk to the spouse of every dentist, it's more for them. It's to have something on file that says, "If something happens to me, we can move efficiently towards solving that issue."
Paul Goodman
And I'll add here, and Rob works with buyers a lot. How, when you're on a deal, Rob, and they have something like this, I'm assuming the buyers are probably a lot more confident in what they're buying, whether it's done as an emergency, an urgency. But when it's not like, "Hey, let's get out the shoebox of receipts from this practice and unwind it." So maybe could you add, as an attorney who is navigating this with buyers, why a seller would want—why an owner would want to have this done so they can feel prepared and their family can be protected, not necessarily from disaster, just in making the next step in their life.
Rob Montgomery
Yeah, I mean, look, it's—it's important to have this done before you start the conversation for both sides, you know. And initially, you know, it's more falls on the lap of the—of the seller because they ultimately they know what they got. They're the ones that are getting the appraisal frequently or the valuation. But, you know, where we do see people run into problems is, yeah, Paul. They start talking about the deal. "Well, I'm going to sell you 50 for whatever it's valued at." You know, and go back to what we were talking about a couple of minutes ago. Is that a good deal for you or not? And then, you know, if you start throwing that out, you have that conversation. Then you come back and you look at the numbers. They're like, "Whoa, I regret that." Very hard to put that genie back in the bottle, as you said. Right. And—and generally, once you say something and then go back on it. That's—that's not a strategy for successful negotiation. It starts to make people distrustful, and it's also not fair to the—to the buyer. So if the buyer says, "Okay, yeah, this is what I—you've told me you're going to do," it sounds good to me. I've engaged my accountant. I've engaged a lawyer, and then they're looking at this deal. And then all of a sudden, the seller has finally become educated after they already started the conversation. Now they know the economic impact of what they're proposing to do, and they don't like it. Now, now the seller, I'm sorry, the buyer has to go back and talk to their people and say, like, "Oh, yeah, they changed it now, and now it's something different," you know. And—and so, and that costs its time, money, delay. So, you know, where in order to do these things properly, you need to know again what the numbers are, have an understanding that they work for you, they need to work for the other side, and then that's the basis. Proceeding, but just to start, like, just freestyling, like, "Hey, this many percent for this, this, this amount of valuation," and it's like, yeah, but there are all these other details. As Matt said, it's the structure that matters. You know, is this seller going to stay on and still work full time in this partnership? Are they going to cut back a day? Are they going to cut back two days? Like, that matters when you're assessing these deals, and they're the things that you need to get your arms around as a seller before you start the conversation to present it to the buyer, so that the buyer can then take that, do their due diligence, and then everybody knows what they're getting, so that after, you know, three months after the deal closes, nobody's surprised, angry, or disappointed. You know, and the people that don't do that, that say, "Yeah, I just took what was behind door number one. Oh, wow, we found out three months later. It's good for me, not good for me, good for you." Like, "Yeah, you want to go get lunch?" You know, like, it's like it doesn't—it doesn't work, and it's just so avoidable.
Paul Goodman
What I'm hearing here is we've done a couple things. Is here we talked about this practice. We've talked about the value of getting valuations. Talked about working with advisors. Talked about making decisions before you need to need to make these decisions. What I want to add next is when a dentist does this, right? It doesn't have to be. And you're right, Matt. I've dealt with this both personally and professionally. Bad, unexpected bad things happening, and having to make a decision. But that actually is not most of the time. Most of the time, you're getting information to make things better. So when they do this, my assumption is they can work on things with their practice to make it more attractive to sell. Whether that's from a profitability standpoint or from a process standpoint, am I correct in thinking that you've reviewed their valuation? You've said, "Hey, this $2 million practice has a value of 1.5 million. If you want to make it higher, you have to do this. If you want to make it more attractive, you would do this." Are those the type of things you talk about with your clients?
Matthew Howard
Yeah, all the time. And I think, I think that, you know, again, there's—there's brokers that do valuations, and it's, you know, a two-pager, right, that just kind of tells, "Hey, based on their experience," and they're—they know their market, right? They're probably nailing the value. The problem is, have we told the story? What's the good, the bad, and the ugly? You know, what is a buyer going to ask questions about? How can we already know the answer, or how can maybe even solve some of these issues to not have a buyer or that potential associate, or just absolutely maximize this wonderful, you know, thing that we have that we own to—to do better for the owner over time. So to me, it is—it is one part, you know, looking at what is the value today, but really it's looking forward. And if we are several years out, and we do have time to plan, and we are integrated into the process, we can go to market, and then the owner can even give their one-minute elevator speech to the associate if they're buying in or whatever kind of transaction it is. They can actually answer questions in an efficient elevator one-minute pitch. Instead, we get six months down the road, and we still haven't solved basic issues. And deal fatigue sets in. And guess what? These are where deals die. I mean, Rob and I can talk tell way too many stories about that.
Paul Goodman
So, what I appreciate you sharing that and giving us insight. If there was an intermission, everyone would go have intermission and come back. But at Zoom, it's not. We're going to spend our our last third on the DSO world. But I'm going to bring up a person we both know, and I've taken out this 10-pound weight because Joe McGonigal looks like he spends some time inside of a gym. I think we can enjoy. We can agree, right? You see Joe McGonagall, and we have biceps nevas. Now he is somebody and also a sponsor. They both know that is a broker who acts as an advisor and works with people like yourselves. And now we're just going to talk about this deal that I have kind of made up, but also represents a lot of deals out there. I'm Dr. Paul Goodman. I own a practice that collects $3 million a year. I have one associate dentist, one associate dentist working with me. I make $900,000 a year as a dentist, and my EBITDA is 20%, $600,000. Right? I have my associate doing a fair amount of dentistry. I have a great hygiene department. I've been around the block long enough to realize that when your EBITDA is higher, it's usually you're not doing quite as much work yourself because you have a good hygiene department. You have other people there, so that's why I might only be worth three to $400,000 as an associate in my own practice. But I have a productive associate, productive hygiene department. So we got $300,000 practice. And if you ask Joe McGonigal, I'm going to ask you guys. You can disagree with me. I'm going to assume he could say both DSOs and private practice dentist will be interested in your practice. Would you agree? Both, if you had that practice,
Matthew Howard
Absolutely. Yeah, both. I think. I think any. I mean, leveraging people is the hardest thing we do as CPAs as dentists. And if you're leveraging people and you've got that kind of economic scale, depending on the location. You should have a thriving buyer pool on both sides of the equation.
Paul Goodman
Now, in this scenario, your associate dentist has no desire to own a practice. They have a spouse, and they do not want to be a practice owner. And you want to make your next plan your next step. Rob, if I ask you, a practice of that size run like that, why would some private practice dentist perhaps be reluctant to take that over, like a $3 million practice?
Rob Montgomery
Yeah, I mean, it could be, you know, you know, quote-unquote too big, or they're concerned that they don't want to borrow that much money. These are things that people will say, or they're not able to do the type of dentistry that the seller does, and so they—they're—they're uncomfortable being able to continue the—the revenue at that level. But, you know, as you said, there—there are other people in the practice that are helping produce potentially. But I mean, the thing is, and it used to be a few years ago, even not even a few up until somewhat recently, that it would have been hard for a dentist to get a loan to buy that practice from a typical healthcare lender. Lenders have a much bigger, greater appetite now for larger loans and larger deals if they cash flow and they make sense, which is—which is great for sellers because some a few years ago, somebody that owned that practice really had one buyer, one type of buyer, and that was a DSO.
Paul Goodman
So now, what you're sharing with this audience is the—the potential buyers for this over the past five years have grown, expanded.
Rob Montgomery
Have grown and changed. You know, so you've gone from really DSO only. Now, the DSO deals and the structure of that deal that the DSO is going to put on the table is not as good as it used to be, and, you know, the white knight has arrived, and that's the dental-focused lender who's going to lend to a dentist to buy that practice. So now there's still an off-ramp.
Paul Goodman
I'm not going to like I said, I preserve Zoom HIPAA, but I have a feeling that some of these people in here have practices that would be in this world. So this is really powerful to actually these people watching it. 8 million people will watch this after it's recorded because it will be our most popular one. But right now we have people watching it. So we have this $3 million practice, and good news: there's a lot of positivity. The associate dentist has said, "No matter who you sell this to, I will stay for another three years because I love this practice, and I love my patients, and I produce a million bucks a year, and I make 350, and I will stay, right?" So now we have a commitment from the associate dentist to stay but not buy. Okay, stay but not buy. So we have this $3 million practice. Let's just have a fun time back at the napkin again. We need more napkins for these shows, Lindsay, because I'm going to bring them up. I'm going to start writing on them. It's a profitable practice. Joe McGonigal says someone's going to give you 2.8 million for this practice. Can we agree a $3 million practice of this 2.7? How about 2.7? We both can we all agree on that?
Rob Montgomery
Wait, wait. We're talking about the dentist here, or...
Paul Goodman
A private practice sale of a traditional lending to go out and get money, and the sale price, I know there'll be broker fees, is 2.7. Just for the purpose of this fun discussion, this is just a fun discussion, not real legal and accounting advice, right? So your account and attorney, but so then the person says, "Oh, Joe, I've also heard about these DSO things, and my friend sold to a DSO, and he kind of medium happy about it, right? It's not as good as he thought, or he or she thought. He doesn't hate it. He's waiting to finish out his commitment. But just so I can be sure, could you walk me through what a DSO might offer me for this? Tell us about some of these deals you see. What might I get? I 2.7 is one option, but I go. I want to just make sure, Joe, that the D I get the DSOs to to take a look. What would I be expecting to hear or see, and what should I be aware of, and maybe scared of? Rob, aware and scared, and now I'll let you guys talk about this.
Matthew Howard
Yeah, I mean, I'll start. I mean, ultimately, it will be a higher enterprise value, and what that is, a fancy word for, is the global pot of all the money that they're calculating that is going to funnel your way if X, Y, and Z happens, will certainly be higher. I think of transactions.
Paul Goodman
Give us an example. Would 4.2 million be an example if it does $600,000 a EBITDA?
Matthew Howard
Yeah, something like that.
Paul Goodman
Right? So four points. So they go, "Oh, Paul, don't sell it to this person for 2.7. 4.2 is bigger than 2.7."
Rob Montgomery
Sometimes it can.
Matthew Howard
Literally, yes, but I mean, think about the transaction structure through the prism of risk. Right, the only risk, unless there's clawbacks, which there can even be clawbacks for money that you get paid at close, there can be clawbacks if certain things don't happen after. Transaction, you could actually lose the money they've already paid you, portions of it, not scaring you, just educating you, right? So, prism of risk, the cash at close, if it rhymes with a private practice transaction, then I think we've got something that is interesting. This used to have.
Paul Goodman
Let me interject, and if you guys want to talk dentist sometime, Rob, I think of you like a periodontist, and I think of you like an endodontist, Matt, and I think of—
Matthew Howard
Thank you.
Paul Goodman
Because Joe's kind of the general dentist. So, what is a periodontist? Is a specialist in gum, gum health, implants like that, and an endodontist is a specialist in root canals. And when you're doing a big case for someone, that full mouth rehab, the general dentist, the Rob and the Matt will inter—will talk a lot about the patient. And Rob, you don't know exactly what Matt does, but you learned it in dental school. And Matt, you don't know exactly what Rob does. You know what he does. You don't. You can't do it, but you're—you understand. So you understand what accountants do, Rob, and vice versa. Because Rob, in this world, I—I actually am your client. So if this was fake, I say, "Hey, Rob, 4.2 million is more than 2.7, and I would like to get that alpaca for my office. So I want more money so I can buy myself more toys. How much money at close would this start to make sense? I heard what Matt said, but what would you say?"
Rob Montgomery
Well, I mean, I—I think it's it depends kind of what you want to do going forward. So, you know, with the DSO deal, you got to like the cash at close that you walk away with. Don't—don't count on the equity, you know, being worth more or even anything in some respects. I mean, a lot of the people that are they're kind of, you know, hustling these deals will tell the sellers, "Yeah, you're going to get a second bite of the apple, and when you get a second bite of the apple, it's going to be like you have a lottery ticket." That has not been happening much recently. In recent...
Paul Goodman
You unpack that a little so for our audience because it's your guys are using some technical terms and some slogan terms. Just so if I have this $4.2 million deal and I get the $3 million at close and I have this 1.2 million, the second bite of the apple would mean that that 1.2 million could be sold for 2.4 million. Could be. That's the happy ending. It also could be sold, if my grandmother was here, for bupkis, which is nothing, right?
Rob Montgomery
It happened recently too. It happened recently. DSOs, yeah.
Paul Goodman
So as you're helping me, your client in this, you know, world, in this fun game, it let's say why are cashes at close for DSOs? Why has—why is that sometimes only 2.1 of the 4.2? Why has that gone down lower? Because years ago I got 90% at close. What? Why is that?
Rob Montgomery
Right, it's changed. Yeah, it's just—it's the market. You know, like they can't pay as much for these practices. So the only way they can't pay that much less and be able to get deals done. So now, you know, the valuations are the same, but the cash that they actually have to part with has greatly reduced, and so it's—at least that's my observation.
Matthew Howard
Yeah, it's back when interest rates were low. Everybody looked like a genius. It was free money, right? And so that's where you had that element where they were willing to part with capital because they could turn capital and do a lot more dollars through leverage, right? As interest rates have come up, they want to hold on to that dry powder because they can't make it go as far. Because again, the way that a DSO continues to add value, recap higher, guess what? You got to grow, and you got to grow by a very tepid pace, a good pace. And so the only way they can grow is by having direct capital. By having direct capital, they grow and they acquire more practice. They consolidate all of the things that we...
Paul Goodman
So they're not as open to giving as much at close, right? And, you know, we'll—we're going to wrap up in about 10 minutes. I want to get to a couple things. So I'm with you guys. So I'm Paul Goodman, 4.2 million. I'm getting $3 million at close. And what you're both saying, as someone who does this every day, is if I'm not happy with that 3 million, don't do the deal. Would you say that?
Rob Montgomery
Yes.
Paul Goodman
Now I want to. I want to.
Rob Montgomery
Let me—let me throw a curveball. Let me just throw one thing on top of this before, because I want to don't want to leave the conversation about this. Even if all things are equal, same cash in the private deal as a DSO deal. If it depends on what you're looking to do the next few years, if you if you're...
Paul Goodman
I am okay just because I know where you're going, and I want to—I want this story to I'm okay continuing to work for three years. Okay, sure, in any capacity, right? A private dentist could buy me as their fourth or fifth practice, and I'll work for them for three years. At DSO, I'm making this like a fairly easy story to follow, right? I know there's nuances, but I'm talking about me, Paul, right? I'll do three more years.
Rob Montgomery
Well, Paul, let me stop you, but you still can't discount this because if you're—if you're going to work for three more years and you're going to make $500,000 less a year as an...
Paul Goodman
This is like, like a married couple, you're finishing my sentences.
Rob Montgomery
Because we spent a lot of time together, I had to do that.
Paul Goodman
Because, Rob, hold on, but don't say it yet. Because this audience needs me the—the more the less expert. Because I'm coming to this. This is what I was talking about, Matt, before you jumped on. In this scenario, if I get the $3 million and I'm happy, okay with that, or I get the $2.7 million, and I'm happy, and I'm going to work for three years, and I'm going to let you have this moment, Rob. I was making 900 as the owner. Right now, I'm down to 400, and if you sell to the DSO, my income has dropped dramatically, and I have to now tell my family our lifestyle could have to change. Is that something that would could happen?
Rob Montgomery
Yes. Yes.
Paul Goodman
And have you dealt with clients who have found this out after the ink another ink has dried? Right. Nobody doesn't. After the DocuSign has dried.
Rob Montgomery
Not my clients. These are people—people that we didn't represent in the deal come to us after us and have these conversations. Yes, my clients don't because my clients make it to Matt and people like Matt to get the numbers squared away, you know. But here, let me just say this, Paul: if you held on to the practice for three more years, you're still going to work every day. You could have made another $2.7 million, you know. So, did you really need to do the deal today? Right?
Paul Goodman
Exactly. Matt, why don't you add there, Matt? Because I think, to me, and I was saying this the other day, actually, nobody has money. It doesn't matter where you are, or whether how—how people tell you how lucky you are to make the money you make, whether you are a 27-year-old or a 57-year-old. No one's going to be like, "Hey, I can't wait for my income to be reduced and basically do the same clinical job." For the time being, we'll put the management stuff aside. So, have you had to have hard conversations with clients before they're about to DocuSign?
Matthew Howard
Absolutely. I mean, I think actually, what we try to do is visualize it. We try to showcase what would your world look like if you just kept owning and making some very baseline assumptions, not making crazy assumptions, saying inflationary growth. That's it. If you just kept on for the next three to four, and usually it's five years, work back, right? What would your world look like from a pie? And then what would your life look like under this DSO? And guess what? We have to make some bad assumptions on what does that equity component look like. But even so, I want them to make the educated decision of understanding what the dynamics would look like if the world equity looks like nothing, or if the joint venture equity doesn't materialize, or if they never are able to sell last 10% of their ownership. All of these things that just need to be just again, as using your doctor, dentist illustrations, it has to be absolutely has to be prescribed correctly. We have to look at the patient because between Rob and I, looking at the patient together, thinking strategically, if there's—if there's reasons to do this deal, a DSO deal, and again, I've got clients that have health issues of, you know, important parties in their practice. There are good reasons to do a deal like this, but man, eyes wide open is absolutely necessity.
Paul Goodman
Yeah, I like that, Rob. We're going to have each of you are going to have some closing remarks here in a minute. But before we get to that, anything you wanted to add to that conversation?
Rob Montgomery
No, and that's that's one of the things that Matt really does great because there is another option, you know, which is what if I continue to own and I sell in a couple of years, and—and then—and to be able to make these decisions, you have to have the numbers in front of you to understand because it's just like saying, like, a baseball manager is just like putting somebody up as a pinch hitter with the bases loaded because he's got a hunch, you know, like nobody does that anymore.
Paul Goodman
Yeah, look at baseball. Sometimes they're all standing on one side of the field. That didn't happen back in my day.
Rob Montgomery
This is right, and yeah, and you talked about McGonagall too. I mean, Joe McGonigal. I mean, great broker. He'll have this conversation. I've—I've been a party to this conversation where he says, "You know what? Maybe you shouldn't sell now. Maybe you should come back and talk to me in two or three years, you know, and then when you're ready to retire, and let's find a dentist to buy your practice because you need somebody to present whether, you know, if you have a good broker, certainly you want your good accountant to present this these options to you so that you understand what you're doing. And it's not just one option. Not—you should never go into any of this saying I'm only going to sell to an associate, or I'm going to sell in a couple years. Know all the options, look at them, understand them from a legal and personal and professional and financial standpoint, and then make an informed decision. And guess what, Paul? That usually turns out just fine.
Paul Goodman
Right? And that's why, I mean, it's—it's such what I want to get to with the patient. We talk about giving patients multiple treatment plans with pros and cons that fit into their life. Right? Oh, you want your teeth to look beautiful, but you never can bite into hey the apple again. Is that the life you want to live? Because you seem like someone who chews Jolly Ranchers all the time. So if I make you beautiful teeth that you eat Jolly Ranchers, you're. To break them, right? So those are the those are the conversations dentists have with sophistication with their patients at the age of 50 because they've been around the block. But when they come to this world, they need people like you to do that. So now I need closing remarks from you guys. Did a great job, Matt. I'll let you go first. Anything you want to wrap this group up with? Somebody's watching this now or three years from now, and they hear this at the end. You got 60 seconds to tell them anything you would like.
Matthew Howard
Yeah, I think going back to your patient remark, like the way that we can diagnose the patient the best between Rob and I, layering on the—the what they want, what they what their vision is for an eventual transaction. If I'm talking to the 50-year-old dentist owners right now, please, please, please. If I could just get one thing through to you, get a good team built, answer all the questions before, and think strategically five years before. Please don't wait until your buddy or your friend down the road sells their practice. I should sell my practice, and then you'd start the process. You start shooting from the hip, please start strategically. If we can diagnose issues, if we can take them off the—the table, if we can find that great partner to work with you for five years, start transferring some of the risk of ownership and having a great partner to mentor. Is it isn't that that not the coolest thing about dental? Is that a lot of owners do want that conduit, but boy does it take good planning! Business marriage is hard, and it's on the rise. And that's where Rob and I work together a lot because that's where things can go very wrong if we don't do a good job on the front end.
Paul Goodman
Awesome job, Matt. Rob, I'll let you finish this up.
Rob Montgomery
Yeah, it's a great point, Matt. You know, and with the sort of the—the DSOs not being as appealing from a deal structure standpoint, we are seeing more partnerships. So it's important to do them well and to do them right. And it can be, if it's properly structured, it's a good thing. But so much of this is planning. You know, if you do it in advance, like Matt says, you can deal with the landlord and get those lease issues. You can make sure your associate agreements are right. You can really set the table and ensure success. And again, with all this stuff, you know that you don't—you don't need to do bad deals. The right planning, doing the right things at the right time with the right people, you can ensure success here. And, you know, I think too that the importance of work that that Matt and I do well together too is, you know, you don't—you don't have to make sure your team is working together. You just don't want a CPA out there doing evaluation and then a lawyer doing documents. I mean, Matt needs to know and convey to me that he's made certain assumptions about the structure of this deal when he said that this is the cash flow, and then I have to know what those are so that I make sure that I incorporate that structure that Matt used as those assumptions into the actual deal. So if Matt's just doing Matt and Rob's doing Rob, then the client doesn't get the—the full service that they need. So it's really important to for us to work together. And I love working with Matt on this stuff.
Paul Goodman
This is the client-side monster. Take a picture, team, of me on this, and you want to avoid this. And I say this to my two friends: You will connect more with dentist if you say when you do a big case, the endodontist has to know what the periodontist is going to do next. And when you do a big case, the periodontist has to talk to the endodontist because if they think you're going to extract a tooth for an implant, and you are planning to maintain that tooth to hold in teeth for a long time, you're not going to get to the end result, and that's what you guys do with these deals. And it can't be done in silos. And it's, you know, the biggest financial decision this dentist will make in their entire life. And they need people like you on their team. So thanks so much, guys. We'll get this recording out through dentalnachos.com. Stick around for a minute, and everyone else who took time to watch live, thanks for watching on demand. We appreciate it. Thanks so much, guys.

.png)
.png)
.png)

.png)